You Need A Budget Software
Casey

Wow! You saved more than you spent!

Last week I stopped by the grocery store on my way home from work with the specific task of buying some things that we needed, which also happened to be low-price-leaders for the week. Armed with my “club card” and with an iron will to only buy the true bargains that we truly needed, I entered the store like a man with a mission.

Attack! . . . Dodge! . . . Swerve! . . . Attack again!

I quickly and systematically went to those parts of the store with the best deals (that I also needed). I grabbed 10 lbs of Nectarines for $1 a pound. Then I went for the tomatoes, but as I was loading up the bag I realized that the 10 lbs for $10 was exactly that – if you buy anything less you pay $3.27 per pound! Sneaky little devils.

But I couldn’t use 10 lbs of tomatoes, so they didn’t get me - I swerved just in time. Next, on to the roast for $1.49 per pound . . . you get the picture. A couple times they almost got me, but each time I escaped. I felt pretty proud of myself on the way to the register.

You see, I only enter that particular store when on this kind of mission, and I never buy the other outrageously priced stuff while I am there. I try to beat them at their game, and I felt like I had.

The funniest comment I have heard in a while

So the lady at the register rings it all up and tells me it comes to $30.47. Then, as she looks at the receipt she proclaims, “Wow! You saved more than you spent! Great job!” She said it in all sincerity and with a look of true amazement in her eyes. As I walked away I looked at the receipt and, sure enough, it said that I had spent $30.47 and saved $44.89.

Does anyone else find that comment as funny as I do?

I didn’t save more than I spent! I spent! I spent wisely, but I still spent. I have always found it funny how these stores put the “savings” at the bottom of the receipt. Do they think that I would have spent $2.98 per pound on their nectarines if they hadn’t been on sale? I wouldn’t have, and so I didn’t “save” all the money that they indicated. I spent what I had planned to.

They could have just as easily said that the nectarines usually sell for $15 per pound and I “saved” $140 on the nectarines alone! What a joke. But the funniest part to me was the lady’s sincere awe that I had just saved more than I had spent. I laughed about it most of the way home. (I know, this is the kind of thing that only members of the ABA (Addicted Budgeters Anonymous) would find funny – it’s a warped world that we live in).

So . . . what’s the point?

I cannot count the number of times that I have listened to people tell me about the incredible deal that they just got on _________. As I listen, it almost always becomes apparent to me that _________ was something that they never intended to buy when they went to the store. That’s not a great deal. That’s you getting duped out of your hard earned money, buying something that you never intended to buy.

I don’t care if ________ normally costs $100 and you just got it for $25 – you just spent $25! You didn’t save $75, you spent $25. (The exceptions to this would be, 1. You turn around and sell it for more than $25 or, 2. you were already in the market for this item and needed to buy it and found a great deal. In these two cases you actually saved/made some money).

So, the next time that someone is trying to convince you of the great deal that is being offered – of all the money that you are “saving” – stop and think. Does spending = saving? Usually not.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • TwitThis
  • del.icio.us
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Mixx

If you enjoyed this post, then make sure you subscribe to our RSS feed!

5 Comments

[Leave a comment]

James@capitalcouplesfinance.com
August 1, 2008

That’s an interesting perspective. You’re absolutely right about it not being “savings” if you wouldn’t have bought it in the first place. Here’s a question: When is it actually “savings” when you buy something at the store? Is it only when you go there with the intention of purchasing something and it happens to be on sale? Or is it even possible to save money when shopping? Is it simply spending less?

Casey Murdock
August 1, 2008

James - In my view, you only save money when you buy something that you already intended to buy, but you get it at a better price.

Now, that could mean that you buy 25 lbs of flour for $10 instead of 5 lbs for $5. You only intended to buy 5 lbs and spend $5, so you actually bought more and spent more than planned. But flour is an ongoing part of your buying intentions and so you saved money (as long as you will use it before it goes bad). It could also mean that you go to the store intending to buy apples for $1.50 per pound and instead buy peaches because they are $1 per pound. You didn’t intend to buy peaches, but you substituted them as something that will serve the same purpose for less money.

The key is whether or not you are buying something that is not needed or planned for just because it is a good deal. If you go to the store for apples and come home with apples, a DVD and a hat (because the DVD and the hat were 50% off) you didn’t save money. You might have gotten a great deal, but you have spent money that you did not plan to, not saved it.

So many people that I talk to are “saving” so much money that they are broke and in debt.

pksublime
August 1, 2008

I use the fact that the “savings” are overrated to my advantage. For a long time, I’ve decided to record those transactions as their “full amount” and put the “savings” into my savings account. I’ve never been faced with savings like that before, and will take off gift cards if they show up in the “savings” line.

I also do this with extended warranties, I politely turn them down and then transfer that amount to a Warranties account, and if the item breaks outside of manufacturers warranty and before end of life, I replace it from the fund.

Casey Murdock
August 1, 2008

pksublime - I love your ideas. I had never thought about doing either, but those ideas are great. I would definitely add those to my list of what I count as saving - but still hold out the caution that if you purchase something that you wouldn’t have otherwise, you have still spent.

I guess the true “savings” in that case would be the amount you put in the bank, minus the amount you spent on the item. I am also curious - have you ever spent more on the items that would have been covered under the warrantee than the amount the warrantee would have cost? I would guess that you haven’t, but I would be curious to know. Especially if you add up the cost of all warrantees on cars that you have past up compared to all costs that would have been covered.

Again, I love the ideas. Thanks for sharing.

Erin
August 1, 2008

Casey,

I’m enjoying your blog posts and this one made me laugh. You and Jesse both need to read “The Tightwad Gazette” by Amy Dacyzyn. She wrote a similar article laying out the same exact points you made.

:)

RSS feed for comments. TrackBack URL

Leave a comment