It's been almost three years since I took the leap and dropped my traditional BCBS health insurance. I am self employed, and every year after my 50th birthday, my premium rose up to 30%, even with a $1,000 deductible and a co-pay on prescriptions.
I approached BCBS about a high deductible plan combined with an HSA, and BCBS was not interested in keeping me at all as a customer.
I joined Assurant/Time Life with a premium locked in at $278 for three years (my last premium with BCBS was $700). With the recession, and extremely irregular income, I have not been able to pay into my HSA as much as I would like. However, I've continued with a $100 automatic deduction from my checking account.
For me, this was the right decision. There have been a few big ticket items that have almost wiped my account clean: A colonoscopy and a crown at the dentist, each over $1,000. I try to space my routine check-ups so that my HSA can accommodate. If I have an emergency, or (God forbid) surgery, I'll probably have to lean on my credit cards for the deductible.
What has changed for me is that I question my doctors about tests and prescriptions. I decline duplicate tests at my GP and OBGYN. I can use my HSA for over the counter meds such as Tylenol and cough drops. I get prescriptions in 90 day vs. 30 day supplies at my local discount membership store, and it's amazing how much is saved!
With all of it on my shoulders, I am finally prompted to take responsibility for my health. I never smoked, and have cut back on alcohol to an occasional social drink at a restaurant. I rarely eat fast food, but don't feel guilty over cheeseburger now and then. Most important, I started walking every day in a local (hilly) park. I've lost 20 pounds, and my cholesterol is back within normal range. I think I'll have other long term benefits, too, especially in bone density. Just as important, walking in a beautiful place and listening to my music has been an amazing stress reliever.

